mainelobsternow.com Reviews
Visit websiteWe independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more ›
Don't have Amazon Prime? Students can get a free 6-Month Amazon Prime trial with free 2-day shipping, unlimited video streaming & more.
If you're not a student, there's also free 30-day trial of Prime.
Join 3,121+ users reviewing Maine Lobster Now®. Read verified ratings and real customer experiences on mainelobsternow.com before you order.
Related articles
1.7 / 5
Average user rating
3121
Total reviews
Why these reviews matter
We aggregate and refresh feedback continuously so you can gauge real customer experience and service quality for mainelobsternow.com.
Brands may not incentivize or pay to hide reviews.
mainelobsternow.com Reviews
Read real experiences from customers of mainelobsternow.com.
Brands may not incentivize or pay to hide reviews.
Write a Review
Please sign in to leave a review for this product.
Don Haugen
March 9, 2026
Dead lobsters and even though they said…
Dead lobsters and even though they said they would credit our gift card they didn't I don't know if they are incompetent or an outright fraud
Kara Conroy Russo
January 7, 2026
Order never shipped
I ordered lobsters to be delivered for Christmas. They offered 12/26 as a delivery date. On 12/24, they realized they couldn’t pack the order on Christmas. After 2 email went unread, I finally negotiated a new date, and a new order as the 1.5 lbs lobsters were unavailable. I spoke with jason who confirmed deliver the next day, 12/31. The order never shipped. Do not use rhis service.
Thom Simmons
December 24, 2025
The worst customer service ever
The worst customer service ever. I had lobster meat sent to me as a birthday gift. The packaging and info inside did not state whether the meat was pre-cooked or not. In reading the fine print on the vacuum-sealed package, it said, "Do not allow to defrost above 38 degrees prior to cooking." One would assume that means it must be cooked, right? Wrong. We cooked what had apparently already been precooked, and the lobster turned out tasteless and rubbery. The worst part: it is impossible to complain to the company. Their chat bot uses canned answers ("go to our website for cooking instructions."). Their website email form responds with the same canned answers. I finally got a 'human' email response, which then repeated the same canned answers, claiming I should have used their website prior to cooking (who consults a a corporate website to cook food? Even that wasn't mentioned on the packaging), and now 'consider the matter closed.' They simply do not want to deal with customers, even when a simple "pre-cooked" wording on the packaging would have changed the entire experience. But they don't care.
Carliss Erickson
December 24, 2025
Horrible
Horrible! Ordered a large amount of snow crab legs for 7 people for our family Christmas Day meal. Only TWO clusters in the package!!!!! Still charged my credit card for hundreds of dollars and had to contact them to get it reversed. And we ordered a month ahead of time so that we were certain to get it right. Seriously, what the heck is wrong with this company. Scam..................Beware
Everett
December 9, 2025
One disgusting lobster tail out of 4
One disgusting lobster tail out of 4. No apology-Just said "we're looking into it"..The date on the package was 10/26 and it was Dec 4 2025. They want to know if it is no good after 4 hours. Do not buy
mark pollio
September 26, 2025
Unshipped items-Refuse to refund money
Unshipped items. Refused to refund for unshipped items. Play games by providing store credit when you obviously would not trust them in the future and order again.
Christine Stull
August 21, 2025
Lobster meat for lobster rolls
The lobster meat and other accoutrements arrived well packaged and as promised however the lobster meat was extremely tough and quite overcooked. It was like trying to eat rubber with no flavor. A shame because I was so looking for to having lobster rolls. I threw out the lobster.
MOBrien
July 19, 2025
Major Disappointment
Major Disappointment — Poor Customer Service and Ruined Family EventWe ordered from Maine Lobster Now to create a special sendoff dinner for our college student with family from the Midwest — many of whom had never had lobster before. What should’ve been a memorable evening turned into a frustrating, expensive disaster.We were told by customer service that a delay notice from UPS was a mistake and that our lobsters were out for delivery and would arrive that day. Based on that, we waited around all afternoon at the delivery location — only for the order to never show up. As a result, we wasted over $250 on the original order and had to send someone out last-minute to spend an additional $300 to throw together a backup dinner. A fun lobster night turned into a basic backyard BBQ that our family can have anytime. Extremely disappointing.To make matters worse, the response from customer service was incredibly dismissive. First, they claimed they weren't responsible for shipping issues. Second, they made us feel foolish for relying on the UPS tracking text regarding the Friday delivery now being Monday— which they themselves told us to trust earlier. And third, we were told that only because we had purchased extra insurance would we be eligible for a refund but we would have to wait until Monday to initiate. There was no empathy, no sense of urgency, and absolutely no attempt to make it right.As a business owner myself, if I had been in their position, I would’ve overnighted a new shipment at my own expense to ensure the customer still got their order in time — and turned a mistake into loyalty. I would’ve been happy to leave a glowing review and return for future business. Instead, I’m left writing this one.We are incredibly disappointed, not only in the failed delivery, but in the total lack of care. This was a special event that cannot be redone — and Maine Lobster Now let us down completely.
Marie Scholle
June 30, 2025
Order from MLN frequently
Order from MLN frequently. They ship promptly to Fairbanks Alaska and never had a bad shipment. Did have an order delayed and cancelled because of UPS but that happens We were re imbursed for the order. MLN is my go to company for all my seafood stuff
Don
March 25, 2025
One of the tails were spoiled.
One of the tails I ordered was completely disgusting. I believe it was spoiled because the texture was just mush and it fell apart when it came out of the shell after cooking. It completely ruined our meal since I didn't have a lobster tail to eat.
Popular Searches
Best Products
Categories
© 2026 RetailCoupons.com. All rights reserved. Time Zone: Pacific Time (US & Canada).