Old Spice manufactures deodorants, antiperspirants, body sprays, and grooming products sold through oldspice.com. This page aggregates shopper ratings and reviews to help you understand what customers experience with Old Spice products before you buy.
Old Spice Reviews
2.3
23 reviews
What Shoppers Say About Old Spice
Created with AI, based on recent reviews
Old Spice receives a low rating of 2.3 out of 5 from 23 shoppers, with significant dissatisfaction evident in reviews. The primary complaint centers on product effectiveness, particularly regarding antiperspirant and deodorant performance. Multiple shoppers report that the product fails to provide adequate underarm protection, with some stating they experience the same level of sweating regardless of application or that protection deteriorates within a couple of hours. Shoppers also note inconsistency between marketing promises and actual product performance. Additionally, several long-time customers express disappointment that the brand's quality has declined compared to earlier decades, and some mention issues with fragrance intensity and longevity.
While a minority of reviewers acknowledge positive aspects such as pleasant scent options (Oasis is mentioned favorably), these positives are substantially outweighed by complaints about core functionality. Some long-time customers express loyalty frustration, citing the availability of superior alternatives like Dove. A few shoppers have also raised concerns about the brand's advertising approach and messaging, though product performance remains the dominant issue driving negative feedback across reviews.
Customer Reviews (23)
Sorted by: Most recentVincent R.Aug 18, 2025
This is seriously the best deodorant available. The aluminum-free formula supports your natural testosterone levels, which matters for any real guy. Outstanding quality and their marketing campaigns are phenomenal.
Amanda K.Jul 21, 2025
Would give zero stars if allowed. This caused chemical burns under both of my armpits, causing intense pain and lasting problems. Old Spice showed no concern about what happened.
James H.Apr 11, 2025
Old Spice High Endurance is top tier deodorant. I quit using it for over a year and couldn't figure out why I'd ever left. Soon as I popped the cap and peeled that plastic, everything came back to me. The scent hits right fresh and robust without being overpowering, and it's got this balanced quality that performs. More importantly, it actually stops odor so I stay fresh around everyone from clients to coworkers. The price is reasonable compared to competitors. I'm never switching again.
Kyle D.Jan 1, 2025
Their stuff doesn't work. I wear it and still sweat profusely even in freezing weather. This ongoing problem has plagued me for a year. Time to switch brands.
Patricia L.Dec 4, 2024
The advertising is terrible and inappropriate. It completely turned me off from purchasing old spice anymore. Whoever came up with that campaign made a terrible choice.
Steven G.Sep 25, 2024
Their shower gels are outstanding. I've been buying them for years and they stay fragrant and excellent. Procter & Gamble really makes some solid products.
Christopher L.Sep 25, 2024
Been using their shower gels for a decade and they remain fantastic. Great fragrances throughout, and Procter & Gamble consistently delivers quality products.
Nathan E.Jul 31, 2024
I've been using old spice soft solid swagger antiperspirant and deodorant for years, and later switched to the stronger version. Lately the formula seems different. The antiperspirant performance has dropped off noticeably. I understand sweating happens with my job, but it used to last way longer. Now I'm lucky to get an hour of dryness before it gives out. The scent deserves the three stars I'm giving because that's held up better. The body wash still works fine too. Hopefully the company can figure out how to bring back the dryness performance that made this product great.
Old Spice Review FAQ
What is Old Spice's current rating on RetailCoupons.com?
Old Spice is rated 2.3 out of 5 based on 23 customer reviews. The rating distribution skews toward lower ratings, with 43 percent of reviews giving one star and 26 percent giving two stars.
What do shoppers say works well about Old Spice?
Positive feedback is limited but includes comments about pleasant scent options, with some shoppers appreciating specific fragrances like Oasis. However, positive comments are significantly outnumbered by complaints.
What are the most common complaints about Old Spice products?
The most frequent complaints involve ineffectiveness of antiperspirant and deodorant functions. Shoppers report that the products fail to prevent sweating, provide inadequate underarm protection, and that protection wears off quickly (sometimes within two hours). Several reviewers also mention that fragrance fades too rapidly and that product quality has declined compared to earlier years.
Do shoppers recommend buying from Old Spice?
Based on the review ratings, shoppers generally do not recommend Old Spice, particularly for those prioritizing effective antiperspirant or deodorant performance. Several reviewers mention preferring competing brands like Dove.
How can I leave a review of Old Spice on RetailCoupons.com?
You can submit a review after purchasing from oldspice.com by visiting this product page and clicking the review submission option. Share your honest experience with product performance, scent, longevity, and value to help other shoppers make informed decisions.