Magic Spoon sells protein-focused breakfast cereals and bars positioned for keto and low-carb diets. This page aggregates shopper ratings and reviews of Magic Spoon to help you understand what customers actually experience when ordering from the company, from product quality and taste to shipping and customer service.
Magicspoon Reviews
What Shoppers Say About Magicspoon
Magic Spoon has a polarized customer base, with 41 percent giving five stars while 23 percent give one star. Shoppers who enjoy the product praise the taste and appreciate it as a keto-friendly option. However, recurring complaints center on three main issues: a greasy or oily coating that leaves an unpleasant mouthfeel, a harsh texture described as similar to Captain Crunch that can scratch the mouth, and concerns about bioengineered ingredients. Several reviewers also note the high price point relative to perceived nutritional value and product quality.
Shipping and logistics present another significant pain point. Multiple customers report problems with the shipping carrier (Speedx and carrier discrepancies), including packages that take weeks to arrive or fail to deliver properly. The combination of premium pricing, texture issues, ingredient concerns, and delivery problems appears to drive negative experiences, even among shoppers who were initially willing to try the product based on brand familiarity.
Customer Reviews (22)
Sorted by: Most recentThe taste actually turned out better than expected, which was nice. But there's this greasy coating that bothers me a lot. I'm fine with butter and good fat in other foods, but not in my breakfast cereal. It left an unpleasant oily feeling in my mouth that I just couldn't get past. Ended up not finishing the box because of it.
I was familiar with their protein bars from Amazon and liked them, so I ordered a bundle straight from the company thinking I'd get a better deal. Big mistake. They used a shipping company called Speedx that doesn't actually deliver packages. Three weeks went by with nothing showing up, so I filed a dispute with my credit card to get my money back. Speedx has terrible reviews for a reason. The company needs to reevaluate who they're partnering with for shipping.
Spent $39 on a box and got excited to dig in. Ate several bowls of different flavors before I discovered they contain bioengineered ingredients. This is a huge problem for me. I'm really concerned about this stuff and how it affects your body. Modified foods mess with your immune system and can cause illness that you might not even realize is happening. Won't be eating this anymore.
Complete rip off. Who spends that kind of money on a box of cereal that has less nutritional value than the box it comes in. Not worth it.
The packaging looks nice but the product itself needs serious work before it should be sold. The taste is off, kind of milky and not very flavorful. It sticks to your teeth like crazy. The biggest issue is the texture, it's like eating crispy sawdust and actually scratches the roof and sides of your mouth worse than Captain Crunch. If you have any chewing sensitivities, skip this completely. The cereal pieces are incredibly hard and tough. The bowl and spoon that came with it are just okay, but they should be nicer given the price. There's also way too much oil in this stuff, and it's not even fortified with nutrients. I bought it hoping it would help with dieting but it just falls short. Even Nutrisystem tastes better, and that's saying something.
I ordered 4 boxes thinking they'd be good for keto. Took forever to arrive, and when I got a delivery notice, the package hadn't actually been delivered to me. The shipping carrier problem is something I keep running into with this company. They claim to use DHL but the box showed up from a different carrier. My package was left on the floor at the entrance, which is not acceptable for a $40 order. The peanut butter flavor I did try has this unpleasant whey protein aftertaste that sits in your mouth and tastes gross. I'm not willing to try the others or order again based on this experience and the shipping disaster.
Imagine if a really weak wizard only half remembered what Froot Loops tasted like and tried to recreate them. That's basically what this is. It's like flavorless cheese puffs that sat near actual Froot Loops in a warehouse somewhere. The flavor is faint and forgettable, like a ghost of a memory you had years ago. The health stuff compared to real Froot Loops is probably better, but who cares when it tastes like nothing. The flavor is weak, the box is tiny, and the price is honestly insulting for what you get. Can't really recommend it.
The cereal itself is actually pretty good, but the company's business practices are really shady. The main issues are the price, which is hard to justify, and the deceptive promotional tactics. They constantly advertise offers that don't actually apply to you. When I contacted them after being disappointed, they promised the deals would work on my next order. They never did. Come to find out those offers only go to new customers, and I felt misled. The company doesn't make this clear anywhere on their site. This bait and switch approach is dishonest, and it's the reason I'm done with them. I won't recommend them to anyone.
These are seriously amazing. What you read online is accurate. It's incredible how low carb they managed to make this, and carbs are definitely a big deal health wise. Plus tons of protein, which is exactly what you want in a breakfast option. Some folks complain about price but that's because they're used to junk food. You're paying for quality. The flavors are unreal. My only complaint is the packaging is pretty small at 200 grams, which is basically two bowls for me. Would be nice if they offered 400 or 500 gram sizes so you don't need to order as often. But honestly, 10 out of 10 on taste and nutrition.
I honestly don't know how anyone could rate this higher than one star in good faith. None of the flavors tasted like what they were supposed to. The texture feels like chalk and the aftertaste is pretty bad. For the price you're paying, this is a real letdown. Most varieties were basically inedible.
Magicspoon Review FAQ
How is Magic Spoon's overall rating calculated?
What do shoppers like about Magic Spoon?
What are the main complaints about Magic Spoon?
Do customers recommend ordering directly from Magic Spoon's website?
How do I write a review for Magic Spoon on RetailCoupons.com?
5 active codes right now. Save before you check out.