Magic Spoon sells protein-focused breakfast cereals and bars positioned for keto and low-carb diets. This page aggregates shopper ratings and reviews of Magic Spoon to help you understand what customers actually experience when ordering from the company, from product quality and taste to shipping and customer service.
Magicspoon Reviews
What Shoppers Say About Magicspoon
Magic Spoon has a polarized customer base, with 41 percent giving five stars while 23 percent give one star. Shoppers who enjoy the product praise the taste and appreciate it as a keto-friendly option. However, recurring complaints center on three main issues: a greasy or oily coating that leaves an unpleasant mouthfeel, a harsh texture described as similar to Captain Crunch that can scratch the mouth, and concerns about bioengineered ingredients. Several reviewers also note the high price point relative to perceived nutritional value and product quality.
Shipping and logistics present another significant pain point. Multiple customers report problems with the shipping carrier (Speedx and carrier discrepancies), including packages that take weeks to arrive or fail to deliver properly. The combination of premium pricing, texture issues, ingredient concerns, and delivery problems appears to drive negative experiences, even among shoppers who were initially willing to try the product based on brand familiarity.
Customer Reviews (22)
Sorted by: Most recentThe peanut butter chocolate chip bars are honestly the worst thing I've ever tasted. They're dry, flavorless, and pretty disappointing. I reached out to the company twice but got no response. The packaging says it comes with a guarantee, so that made it even more frustrating. Save your money and skip this one. Two friends I gave some to agreed completely.
It's actually really good stuff. Hope they manage to get it into grocery stores sometime soon.
This is a fresh and tasty take on breakfast cereal that I'm really enjoying. The variety of flavors is great, and it's become a big part of my healthier eating routine. I have it almost every day now and actually look forward to eating it. I switched to non-dairy milk recently and the flavor profile works really well with different types. I was specifically looking for a cereal with low sugar and high protein, and finding this brand was a game changer. While it costs more than regular cereal, staying on a keto diet is worth the investment. I get it delivered regularly and it helps me stick to my nutrition goals while also satisfying my cravings for sweets. The new flavors keep things interesting and the company really seems to care about making good products. Overall, this is a solid company doing things right.
The cereal itself is really good. The box bundle that comes with the bowls and spoons is a nice gift option, but the bowls run pretty small for the amount of cereal I like to pour.
I've read all kinds of different takes on this cereal, but I'm not on the negative side. One bowl and I was sold. It surprised me in a good way. Sure, cereal shouldn't be this pricey, but I honestly think the quality justifies it. Frosted is my favorite so far and it just tastes incredible.
I know plenty of people have mixed opinions about this brand, but I have to disagree with the negativity. From that first bowl, I was totally hooked. Better than I expected it would be. Look, the price is up there for cereal, but honestly I think it's worth what you pay. My go to flavor is frosted and it just tastes amazing.
The chocolate flavor is definitely worth recommending. It's a smart way to get your protein intake up while keeping carbs down and staying healthy.
Really happy with the chocolate option. It's a smart, nutritious choice if you want to add protein to your diet while keeping carbs low.
I was excited to try this brand. The fruit flavor is solid, though I usually mix it with something else to dial back the sweetness. The cocoa option was pretty bad, went straight to the trash. The peanut butter one is okay, but honestly doesn't taste much like peanut butter. Frosted is fine. Overall I'm not impressed enough to recommend it. I could have returned the boxes that didn't work out, but figured I'd just eat through the three decent ones and move on.
The website works well and ordering is easy. But I have to mention that their review curation is questionable. They seem to pick and choose which reviews show up and present partial reviews to inflate their rating. If you want a real sense of what people think, look at their Amazon listing for the full picture. As for the product itself, the good news is that all four flavors taste pretty good. Creating a healthy grain free cereal that actually tastes great is impressive. The downside is the texture. Early on it's fine when you're expecting grain free cereal to be different. But after eating it every couple of days for a while, the waxy and gummy feeling builds up on you. My son and even my open minded friend started noticing it. Eventually the sticky film coating your teeth and mouth becomes something you're just tired of. It's a nice attempt and worth trying, but the formula needs tweaking. Hopefully they fix the texture issue before another company jumps in and dominates this market segment.
Magicspoon Review FAQ
How is Magic Spoon's overall rating calculated?
What do shoppers like about Magic Spoon?
What are the main complaints about Magic Spoon?
Do customers recommend ordering directly from Magic Spoon's website?
How do I write a review for Magic Spoon on RetailCoupons.com?
5 active codes right now. Save before you check out.