Magic Spoon sells protein-focused breakfast cereals and bars positioned for keto and low-carb diets. This page aggregates shopper ratings and reviews of Magic Spoon to help you understand what customers actually experience when ordering from the company, from product quality and taste to shipping and customer service.
Magicspoon Reviews
3.2
22 reviews
What Shoppers Say About Magicspoon
Created with AI, based on recent reviews
Magic Spoon has a polarized customer base, with 41 percent giving five stars while 23 percent give one star. Shoppers who enjoy the product praise the taste and appreciate it as a keto-friendly option. However, recurring complaints center on three main issues: a greasy or oily coating that leaves an unpleasant mouthfeel, a harsh texture described as similar to Captain Crunch that can scratch the mouth, and concerns about bioengineered ingredients. Several reviewers also note the high price point relative to perceived nutritional value and product quality.
Shipping and logistics present another significant pain point. Multiple customers report problems with the shipping carrier (Speedx and carrier discrepancies), including packages that take weeks to arrive or fail to deliver properly. The combination of premium pricing, texture issues, ingredient concerns, and delivery problems appears to drive negative experiences, even among shoppers who were initially willing to try the product based on brand familiarity.
Customer Reviews (22)
Sorted by: Most recentSpencer L.Apr 27, 2021
This cereal is fantastic. I've been eating cereal my whole life, but when I had to go gluten free for medical reasons, my options disappeared and I lost all my favorite brands. I just stopped eating it for a while. Then my choices seemed to be either expensive and boring, or basic stuff like Cheerios and Chex. That was it. Then I heard about this on a podcast ad and figured I'd try it. I was blown away. These are basically sugar free but taste like regular store bought cereal. Yes, it's expensive, but it completely replaces my old favorites. Fruity is like Fruit Loops. Frosted is shaped and flavored like Frosted Cheerios, except it's much better. The Blueberry flavor is the best thing I've had in a long time. Cinnamon is bold and reminds me of a lighter version of Cinnamon Toast Crunch. Choco and Peanut Butter together are actually really good. They also do seasonal stuff which is either good or great. I had a maple syrup waffle option once that made me happy. They rotate flavors in which keeps things fresh and fun. Box art is cool too.
Trevor N.Apr 27, 2021
This cereal is honestly fantastic. I've always loved cereal, but when I had to switch to gluten free for health reasons, my options got really limited and boring. For a long time I just went without, or stuck with plain options like Cheerios or Chex. Then I heard about this brand on a podcast and decided to give it a shot. Wow, I'm so glad I did. The stuff tastes like regular cereal you'd buy at the store but without all the sugar. Yeah it's pricey, but it actually replaces all my old favorites. The Fruity flavor is basically Fruit Loops, and Frosted tastes like Frosted Cheerios but way better. The new Blueberry is fantastic, honestly the best thing I've eaten in years. Cinnamon has a strong flavor and reminds me of Cinnamon Toast Crunch but not as sweet. Choco and Peanut Butter aren't great solo, but mixing them together is really good. They rotate in seasonal flavors too, and they're either good or amazing. I had a maple waffle flavor once that I absolutely loved. The box designs look great. Definitely worth trying if you're looking for a healthier cereal option.
Magicspoon Review FAQ
How is Magic Spoon's overall rating calculated?
Magic Spoon is rated 3.2 out of 5 based on 22 customer reviews collected by RetailCoupons.com. The rating reflects all submitted feedback, with roughly 41 percent five-star reviews, 23 percent one-star, 18 percent two-star, 14 percent three-star, and 5 percent four-star.
What do shoppers like about Magic Spoon?
Positive reviewers note that the taste often exceeds expectations and appreciate the product as a keto-friendly breakfast option. Customers familiar with Magic Spoon's protein bars from other retailers have expressed interest in ordering directly from the company.
What are the main complaints about Magic Spoon?
The most frequent issues are texture and mouthfeel: a greasy or oily coating, a harsh texture compared to Captain Crunch that can scratch the mouth, and a sticky quality that adheres to teeth. Other complaints include high pricing relative to nutritional value, the presence of bioengineered ingredients, and repeated shipping problems with carriers like Speedx that fail to deliver on time or at all.
Do customers recommend ordering directly from Magic Spoon's website?
Mixed results. Some customers expect better deals ordering directly from the company rather than through Amazon, but several report problematic shipping experiences specific to orders placed on magicspoon.com. Shipping delays, carrier mix-ups, and delivery failures appear common enough that some reviewers suggest caution.
How do I write a review for Magic Spoon on RetailCoupons.com?
You can submit a rating and review after making a purchase from Magic Spoon. Share details about taste, texture, nutritional value, shipping speed, and overall experience to help other shoppers make informed decisions. Honest, specific feedback about what worked or did not work with the product or service is most helpful.
Looking for Magicspoon coupons?
View Magicspoon Coupons
5 active codes right now. Save before you check out.